Opened 10 years ago

Closed 7 years ago

Last modified 6 years ago

#670 closed new feature (invalid)

Proposition : create a Captcha to reduce Spamming

Reported by: jeanyves Owned by:
Priority: minor Milestone: Legacy Resolved
Component: BW Mail Keywords: Spam Captcha
Cc:

Description (last modified by midsch)

This is a proposition (and something which can be prepared as an independent task)

The idea is to make a Captcha mandatory when a member wants to contact another members under certain conditions :

For now I see two conditions :

  • a member who have not yet any positive comment and who is sending a message to another one with the same text as a previous message sent to another member : Captcha. This will reduce the Spam done by copy/paste and the not personal message.
  • a member who have a Flag (given by Safety Team) !ForceACaptcha, will have a Captcha (to reduce his bad ways of sending to much messages, or if he is suspect of being a potential spammer but in a borderline situation (not enough to be kicked), all of this being decided by the Safety Team.

Change History (4)

comment:1 Changed 10 years ago by midsch

  • Description modified (diff)

Is this really useful? If a spammer not mind all the work to visit profiles, copy & paste the mail, click the little "i agree"-checkbox and press return, you won't stop him with a captcha. Easy workaround for this proposal: setup a second account and write a positive comment for the first.

A forced captcha for a potential spammer marked by the security team? Don't you think, if the captcha is an annoyance, the spammer would just set up another profile (with a slightly different strategy)? Which means the whole procedure to stop a spammer starts from the beginning. If the security team has a got hand on a spammer, it'd be more smart to let him go on with logging in and "sending" mails from his account, but blew the mails to virtual nirwana. So the spammer might loose his interest at all by never getting answers.

Nevertheless captchas might be useful at sign up if spambots try to auto-generate accounts.

(BTW: besides this being a very inconvenient way to send out a little bit of spam - compared to usual ways where a spammer sends out 100k mails and more - there have been a lot of talk about fighting spam without really having any.)

comment:2 Changed 10 years ago by jeanyves

I think that spammer are usually vey lazy people, and a Captcha is a real pain for them. The reason is that they have to use the keyboard (for the captcha), and I think it makes a difference. In fact, for now we have had several spammers inside BW (blind spammers) who have been kicked after spamming something between 5, 10 or 100 members.

What I expect with a captcha is to discourage 90% of these spammers. I have no "data" to pretend it will be 90%, but it is just my feeling that it will be 90% at least

comment:3 Changed 7 years ago by planetcruiser

  • Resolution set to invalid
  • Status changed from new to closed

see #1569

comment:4 Changed 6 years ago by TimLoal

  • Milestone changed from unassigned to Legacy Resolved
Note: See TracTickets for help on using tickets.